Nichole “Nicky” Plumley

August 15, 1984 – September 21, 2026

Nichole “Nicky” Plumley, of Columbus, Ohio, was born on August 15, 1984, and passed away on September 21, 2026.

Nicky was a one-of-a-kind person who loved her family, enjoyed making memories, and always had her own way of doing things. Her later years brought her closer to her family and were filled with many good memories that will always be remembered.

She loved being an aunt and spending time with her nieces and nephews — Ava, Laila, Leiliana, Levi, and Lee Jr. She took joy in watching them grow and being part of their lives.

And if you knew Nicky, you probably knew she was a WWE fan. She loved wrestling and could get into the matches, storylines, and all the drama that came with them. It was one of those little things that made her, her.

Nicky was preceded in death by her mother, Tina Klausman, and her grandmother, Dorothy Brown.

She is survived by her father, James Klausman Sr.; her brothers, James Klausman Jr. (Taylor), Lee Tracy, and Eric Broersma; her nieces, Ava, Laila, and Leiliana; her nephews, Levi and Lee Jr.; her cousin, Crystal; and many other loving cousins, family members, and friends.

Nicky will be missed more than words can say. She will be remembered for the person she was, the love she had for her family, the memories she made, and all the little things that made her special.

Visitation for Nicky will be Tuesday, September 29, 2026 from 4 p.m. until time of funeral service at 6 p.m. at the O.R. WOODYARD CO. South Chapel, 1346 S. High St. in Columbus, OH.